Saturday, April 03, 2004

Privacy aspects of THE MATTER OF BMG Canada Inc. et al v. Jane Doe et al

The Canadian and US media have been abuzz with reports that "file sharing is legal in Canada!" (see Google News coverage). The actual decision doesn't, in my view, go that far (much of it seemed to turn on a deficient affidavit and the difficulty of connecting an IP address and a Kazaa screen name), but that's a bit ultra vires my blog. Here we deal with privacy. But fear not, there is some privacy-related analysis in the decision rendered by von Finckenstein J (2004 FCT 488).

Part of the argument advanced by the internet service providers was that they were prohibited from revealing personal information of their subscribers, absent a court order. The parties agreed in advance that the subscribers have an expectation of privacy regarding their identities, pursuant to their subscriber agreements and sections 3 and 5 of PIPEDA. They also agreed that this personal information can be released without the consent of individuals if the court so orders under section 7(3)(c) of PIPEDA.

[13] I read the Norwich and Glaxco Wellcome cases as establishing that the test for granting an equitable bill of discovery involves the following five criteria: ...

Criterion e: the public interests in favour of disclosure must outweigh the legitimate privacy concerns

[36] It is unquestionable but that the protection of privacy is of utmost importance to Canadian society. In the words of Lamer J. in R. v. Dyment, [1988] 2 S.C.R. 417 (S.C.C.): Grounded in man's physical and moral autonomy, privacy is essential for the well-being of the individual. For this reason alone, it is worthy of constitutional protection, but it also has profound significance for the public order.

[37] In respect of the internet specifically, Wilkins J. in Irwin Toy v. Doe (2000), 12 C.P.C. (5th) 103 (Ont. S.C.J.) stated at paras. 10-11: Implicit in the passage of information through the internet by utilization of an alias or pseudonym is the mutual understanding that, to some degree, the identity of the source will be concealed. Some internet service providers inform the users of their services that they will safeguard their privacy and/or conceal their identity and, apparently, they even go so far as to have their privacy policies reviewed and audited for compliance. Generally speaking, it is understood that a person's internet protocol address will not be disclosed. Apparently, some internet service providers require their customers to agree that they will not transmit messages that are defamatory or libellous in exchange for the internet service to take reasonable measures to protect the privacy of the originator of the information. In keeping with the protocol or etiquette developed in the usage of the internet, some degree of privacy or confidentiality with respect to the identity of the internet protocol address of the originator of a message has significant safety value and is in keeping with what should be perceived as being good public policy. As far as I am aware, there is no duty or obligation upon the internet service provider to voluntarily disclose the identity of an internet protocol address, or to provide that information upon request.

[38] Parliament has also recognized the need to protect privacy by enacting PIPEDA, which has as one of its primary purposes the protection of an individual’s right to control the collection, use and disclosure of personal information by private organizations (section 3).

[39] However while the law protects an individual’s right to privacy, privacy cannot be used to protect a person from the application of either civil or criminal liability. Accordingly, there is no limitation in PIPEDA restricting the ability of the Court to order production of documents related to their identity. Section 7(3)(c) allows disclosure without consent if such disclosure is: c) required to comply with a subpoena or warrant issued or an order made by a court, person or body with jurisdiction to compel the production of information, or to comply with rules of court relating to the production of records. (emphasis added).

[40] Thus, both PIPEDA as well as the test set out in Norwich/Glaxco, require the Court to balance privacy rights against the rights of other individuals and the public interest.

[41] This motion is not a novel proceeding. In the past, third parties have been compelled to disclose documents identifying the name and address of a defendant previously identified solely by an Internet Protocol address. In no case have privacy or other concerns weighing against disclosure outweighed the interest in obtaining documents and information necessary to identify the defendants. See: Irwin Toy v. Doe (2000), 12 C.P.C. (5th) 103 (Ont. S.C.J.); Ontario First Nations Limited Partnership v. John Doe (3 June 2002) (Ont.S.C.J.); Canadian Blood Services/Société Canadienne du Sang v. John Doe (June 17, 2002) (Ont. S.C.J.); Wa’el Chehab v. John Doe (October 3, 2003) (Ont. S.C.J.); Kibale v. Canada, [1991] F.C.J. No. 634 (QL) (FC); Loblaw Companies Ltd. v. Aliant Telecom Inc. and Yahoo [2003] N.B.J. No.208 (N.B.Q.B.), online: QL (NBJ).

One thing that surprises me is that there is no obligation on the part of the ISPs to inform the "owners" of the IP addresses that their information is the subject of an application for an equitable bill of discovery, affording them the opportunity to retain counsel and -- anonymously - resiting the application. To do otherwise seems to put too much discretion in the hands of the ISPs. Afterall, they choose whether to resit the discovery request.

Thursday, April 01, 2004

Article: Turning online privacy into a joke

Donal Daly of the Customer Respect Group has a very interesting commentary on CNet today about the importance of privacy policies in communicating respect to customers. They conducted a survey that underscores the importance of a true, meaningful and customer-friendly privacy policy:

Turning online privacy into a joke | Perspectives | CNET News.com:
"In a survey of the adult online population, conducted by The Customer Respect Group in February 2004, the importance of respectful treatment of consumers' privacy concerns was underlined by some dramatic findings. When survey participants were asked how much they care about a company's privacy policy when invited to enter personal information to a Web site, 22.4 percent responded that in the absence of a privacy policy, they would not offer the information. A further 26.6 percent echoed this sentiment by indicating that if they were unhappy with a company's privacy policy they would leave the site. "

Monday, March 29, 2004

Article: Outsourced UCSF notes highlight privacy risk / How one offshore worker sent tremor through medical system

The heated debate over outsourcing in the United States has included some serious dicussion of privacy issues related to the practice of sending personal information overseas. The San Francisco Chronicle has published a series of articles on outsourcing, which includes one that focuses on this issue in particular.

SPECIAL REPORT / Looking Offshore / Outsourced UCSF notes highlight privacy risk / How one offshore worker sent tremor through medical system: "American jobs have been moving offshore for years, primarily manufacturing work seeking out lower-paid workers abroad. The outsourcing of people's personal information, though, is a relatively new phenomenon -- opening the door to identity theft, fraud and other criminal activities.

'We've reached the point where American companies ship personal information outside the country and tell customers to check their privacy at the shore,' said Rep. Edward Markey, D-Mass., one of the leading privacy advocates on Capitol Hill.

Lubna Baloch's run-in with UCSF demonstrates that the safety of outsourced information can never be guaranteed -- no matter how stringent the safeguards -- and offers the most glaring example to date of how a disgruntled overseas worker can violate the privacy rights of U.S. citizens. "

Concerns related to the confidentiality of personal information in outsourcing are, in my view, likely to be among the most compelling arguments in this debate. Most other concerns relate to job losses, but this issue is one of the only ones that speaks to the protection of consumers. Legislators in the US should consider the alternative of "nearshore" outsourcing to Canada, which has been a growth industry for the Atlantic Provinces in Canada. (See, for example, Keane's great growth in Nova Scotia and EDS's expansion in Nova Scotia.) Companies can take advantage of much lower costs, highly-skilled employees and enforceable privacy laws that are actually stronger than those in the United States.

Article: It's a matter of regaining trust in technology

Australia's The Age publication has a very interesting article on trust and customer relationships. Many businesses have sadly let their customers down and have destroyed the trust that is essential to taking advantage of advanced customer relationship management.

It's a matter of regaining trust in technology - Next - theage.com.au:
"It is not only a problem for the paranoid, because according to Longstaff, 'There has been a precipitous decline in trust in everything because of the public perception of the gap between what someone says and what they do. In terms of technology the gap between what technology promises and what is delivered has been apparent. And the gap between a promise and delivery always gives rise to a decline in trust.'

CRM technology has battled one of the biggest such gaps - because the slick marketing promises of vendors were not easily or cheaply delivered, and only now, several years after the first expensive systems went in, are CRM systems delivering on those promises. Julian Beavis, a vice-president of Teradata, which sells data warehousing and CRM tools, acknowledges that, 'The industry is renowned for grossly simplifying what it takes to do this'.

'It has gone some way to regaining its credibility, and people like the National (Australia Bank, which won an award for its database system in 2003) are making it work.

'The fundamental thing to make CRM work is trust, and that has been squandered, and now we have to get it back,' Beavis says. Getting it back, he believes, will require consumers to experience an alluring level of service underpinned by CRM, which will entice them and eventually rebuild their trust."

Sunday, March 28, 2004

White Paper: Privacy and the tourism industry

A couple of weeks ago, I spoke at the Tourism Industry Association of PEI on the impact of PIPEDA on their sector. As a hand-out, I wrote a brief article entitled Privacy and the Tourism Industry. National Privacy Services Inc. has designed a privacy compliance program for the tourism sector, which is, I believe, the first of its kind. It includes:

  • Privacy manual;
  • Multi-media training CD for privacy officers and staff;
  • Complete consent strategy;
  • Model privacy policies; and
  • Model contractor agreeements.

The second-part, which is optional, is also a first of its kind for the industry. For a low monthly fee, NPSi can act as a company's privacy officer. This allows smaller businesses to take advantage of professional privacy support that they would never be able to afford in-house. More information is available at http://www.privlaw.com.

Thursday, March 25, 2004

Incident: Net firm admits leak of data about 1.4 M clients

The Japan Times is reporting about an incident that occurred last year that probably compromised the personal information of approximately 1,400,000 clients:

The Japan Times Online:

"Net firm admits '03 data leak may affect 1.4 million clients

ACCA Networks Co., a high-speed Internet-access wholesaler, confirmed Thursday that information on some of its customers has been leaked, adding that the leak, which apparently occurred about a year ago, may involve data on about 1.4 million people.

ACCA President Yoshio Sakata said the company acknowledges that personal data on at least 201 customers have been leaked to a third party. He did not rule out the possibility that data on all of ACCA's 1.1 million customers have been leaked, as well as data on some 300,000 people who once were subscribers to the company's services."

Article: Don't 'creep out' your customers

This American article talks about the need to be sensitive to customers when you are dealing with their personal information. The example given probaly woudn't fly in Canada under PIPEDA, but the general theme of the article makes sense:

SearchCRM.com | Don't 'creep out' your customers:

"BALTIMORE -- When it comes to customer privacy, marketers have to do more than just obey the law, says Gartner analyst Adam Sarner. They have to avoid the 'creepiness factor.'

Speaking Monday at the Gartner CRM Summit, Sarner described how he was once contacted by a mortgage company that seemed to be almost flaunting the information it had gathered about him.

'[The letter] said: 'Dear Mr. Sarner, we have used your publicly available records and understand that you pay X amount for your house at X percent,'' Sarner said. 'Creepy, right? 'We were digging around in your data, and this is all the stuff that we know about you.' It kind of creeps you out. ... You have to understand that [people] are a little touchy about this.'"

Tuesday, March 23, 2004

Release: Privacy Law Spurs Jump in Shredding Business

This should come as no surprise:

Privacy Law Spurs Jump in Shredding Business:
"Proshred Sees Accelerated Expansion of Its Door-to-Door Shredding Services As Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act Takes Full Effect

TORONTO, March 23 /CNW/ - With the Personal Information Protection and Electronics Act now in full effect in Canada after a three-year phased-in program, Canadian businesses are increasingly turning to shredding services for assistance in complying with the law's prohibition against disclosing personal information collected during the normal course of commercial activities.

Proshred Security International Inc., Canada's largest mobile shredding service with offices in 350 cities across the country, has seen surging interest in the use of its door-to-door document destruction services by companies and organizations wishing to avoid potential liability under the privacy law.

The company's client roster has expanded by 15 percent in the last six months, with a majority of new customers citing the law as a key reason for coming on board. Inquiries have continued to flow in since January 1 as businesses that had delayed changing their document retention and destruction procedures are scrambling to protect themselves.

'We had a number of proposals with large companies that didn't go anywhere for months or even years because there appeared to be no pressing need for a shredding service,' said Ron Campbell, Proshred President and CEO. 'Now we're seeing those proposals being funded because of this privacy legislation.'

Privacy without tears: In addition to helping uphold the law's ban on unauthorized personal information disclosure by ensuring that information is destroyed before it can be used for illicit purposes, shredding can minimize the burden created by the provision of the law that requires companies to supply all information they have on a specific individual upon request."

Monday, March 22, 2004

Article: More on the Equifax breach

Today's Globe and Mail has another article on the Equifax credit report breach, which was widely publicised last week:

The Globe and Mail: Credit breach too easy, consumer group says -- Critics argue Equifax case underscores how simple it is to abuse confidential files:

"VANCOUVER -- A security breach that allowed criminals to gain access to 1,400 confidential credit files at Equifax Canada was a crime waiting to happen, the president of Consumer Federation Canada says.

'This could have been prevented,' said Dan Barnabic, whose non-profit consumer advocacy group is lobbying the government to tighten regulations covering credit-reporting agencies. Mr. Barnabic said that to access the credit reports at a credit-reporting agency such as Equifax, all a criminal needs to do is set up a front operation."

Friday, March 19, 2004

Article: The Hindu Business Line : They still get in!

From India, an article on spam that misunderstands what PIPEDA is supposed to do about spam.

The Hindu Business Line : They still get in!: "In Canada, the PIPEDA (Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents) Act has been enacted to have a check on and control spamming. Likewise, anyone in Utah receiving banned spam could sue the sender, even if the message originated from out of state. "