Class action lawsuit? There’s an app for that

Just posted over at slaw.ca:

Class action lawsuit? There’s an app for that — Slaw

You may have seen the recent Wall Street Journal article on the privacy implications of certain iPhone, iPod Touch and Android apps that disclose information to advertising networks without the explicit knowledge of the user. It didn't take long, but now a class action lawsuit filed in California against Apple for allowing this to happen. See: Apple sued over privacy in iPhone, iPad apps | Apple - CNET News.

I think that this lawsuit is directed at the wrong party (Apple Computer Inc.) and, if it is at all successful, will be harmful to the internet.

This is similar to going after Facebook for everything that their app developers do. Where on party provides a platform (in this case, a mobile device) and another party builds applications on that platform, the key issue that needs to be addressed where privacy is concerned is “where should accountability for privacy lie?” Getting it wrong will stifle innovation in this currently burgeoning area of the Internet ecosystem. Placing all the responsibility on the platform provider will discourage innovators from making new technologies available to the public, to the detriment of those users who are supposed to be protected by privacy rules. Instead, third-party service and application providers should be responsible to users (and to the courts) for their collection, use and disclosure of personal information.

Just imagine what might happen if the already restrictive Apple is found liable for providing app developers too much latitude in structuring their apps. Would this encourage innovation in applications for users? Nope.