Monday, April 19, 2004

Article: Weak enforcement undermines privacy laws

Michael Geist, one of Canada's most respected technology lawyers, has a very interesting comment in Today's Toronto Star. He argues that the federal Privacy Commissioner needs to take some affirmative steps before privacy protection in Canada becomes more bark than bite. In many ways, the Commissioner's office is hamstrung by a lack of resources following the scandals involving the former Commissioner, George Radwanski.

TheStar.com - Weak enforcement undermines privacy laws:

"If the commissioner's office is to take the lead on cutting edge issues and increase its enforcement activity, the federal government must step up to the plate to provide it with much-needed resources.

In the wake of last year's scandal involving former privacy commissioner George Radwanski, the office has faced significant budget pressures that have constrained new hiring and sadly transformed the current privacy legislation into a complaints-only-driven process.

While there is no doubt the will at the commissioner's office to ensure that PIPEDA meets expectations, the federal government must help pave the way.

It is evident that privacy laws without effective enforcement and genuine transparency may provide Canadians with little more than placebo privacy protection.

Ensuring that this does not happen is, in the words of the privacy commissioner, a question of responsibility."

Full article ...

Saturday, April 17, 2004

Privacy Officer Training

National Privacy Services Inc. is going to be offering its Privacy Officer Training program in Ottawa (May 19-20) and Toronto (May 17-18) next month. The two-day course is designed to provide the necessary training and tools for businesses to begin to implement privacy law compliance in their organizations. The course was originally designed by McInnes Cooper's privacy law practice group when clients regularly asked how and where privacy officers can get the training necessary to undertake the role in an informed and professional manner. The brochure [PDF] is available from the National Privacy Services Inc. website.

The two-day privacy officer training program provides an in-depth review of PIPEDA and its myriad exceptions. Key decisions of the Office of the Privacy Commissioner are reviewed, as are security and privacy issues. It also includes specific assistance for dealing with inquiries and complaints.

Wednesday, April 14, 2004

Article: New privacy sprouts forest of complaints

Today's Toronto Star has a very interesting article that highlights something that I have been trying to emphasizes to my clients for some time: the most important thing that a business must do to comply with PIPEDA and to avoid complaints is to communicate with its customers. Principle 2, from the CSA Model Code, requires a business to take reasonable steps to bring to an individual's attention the purpose for which information is being collected. This communication forms the foundation for the "knowledge and consent" that are required under "Principle 3 - Consent". Many commentators emphasize that PIPEDA is about consent, but this consent has to be based on the identification of purposes. If you tell you customers what you propose to do, there won't be any uncertainty or confusion and, therefore, the business is much less likely to get a complaint.

TheStar.com - New privacy sprouts forest of complaints:
"Canada's privacy watchdog says a 'communications gap' forming between businesses and consumers may be partly to blame for an increase in complaints since new federal privacy legislation went into full force on Jan. 1.

The law requires businesses, large and small, to put systems in place that will make sure customer information is secure, accurate, gathered with consent and not used beyond a stated purpose.

Heather Black, assistant federal privacy commissioner, said Canadians are taking advantage of their newfound privacy rights but many businesses, when asked to explain how and why they collect and use customer information, aren't providing adequate answers.

'When people ask why they're being asked for this information, they're not getting very satisfactory responses,' said Black. 'So it really is a communications gap.'

The commission began noticing this trend in January, specifically in the retail sector. Black said a number of people have filed complaints against certain retail outlets that require customers to provide their names, phone numbers and addresses when goods are returned for refund or exchange."

Full article ...

Monday, April 12, 2004

Article: Employment law myths

In today's National Post, Howard Levitt, counsel to Lang Michener, takes a pretty aggressive stand with respect to PIPEDA. His sentiments about the constitutionality are shared by others, but I was surprised to read that he suggests ignoring PIPEDA. Most privacy lawyers with whom I speak are of the view that PIPEDA should be followed until it is declared to be unconstitutional:

"4. Privacy legislation applies across Canada.

The federal privacy legislation constitutionality provided that, if similar legislation was not passed in each province by January 1, 2004, the federal legislation would apply provincially. Many provinces, including Ontario, have not yet passed Privacy Acts. However, virtually everyone is conducting themselves as if the federal privacy legislation applies. It does not. Despite the wording of that legislation, the federal government lacks the constitutional power to impose privacy legislation on the provinces and no attempt to do so would survive legal challenge. Therefore, contrary to seemingly everyone's belief, there is presently no effective, binding privacy legislation in most of Canada."

This is very aggressive and, at least to this point, many Courts have been applying PIPEDA without hesitation. It is true that the federal government has no constitutional way to regulate the provincially regulated workplace, but PIPEDA does not purport to operate there.

Saturday, April 10, 2004

Correction re: Mathew Englander

Mathew Englander, to whom I referred a while back, has e-mailed me a correction about an entry in PIPEDA and Canadian Privacy Law. I had been told that his complaint had arrived by e-mail, having been sent at the stroke of midnight 2001. Mr. Englander writes:

I just came across the reference to me on your blog (http://pipeda.blogspot.com/2004_01_04_pipeda_archive.html#107338559447219057).

It's ironic that your "sources at the Office of the Privacy Commissioner" infringed on my privacy by telling you that my complaint "was sent by e-mail on January 1, 2001 at 12:01 am." The Privacy Commissioner should not unnecessarily divulge details about complaints and complainants.

In any event the information is wrong. I did not file my complaint by e-mail.

You can post this email on your web site if you like, but of course not my email address (which is a disposable address anyway).

Mathew Englander

As they say, it is always better to get your information first hand ...

Wednesday, April 07, 2004

Article: Privacy officer for hire

Since the launch of National Privacy Services, we've gotten some quite favourable coverage in the media. ConnectIT had the following article in today's edition:

[ ConnectIT e-News Daily ]:
"Privacy officer for hire
6 April, 2004
by Liam Lahey

Security solutions provider Thor Solutions Inc. and law firm McInnes Cooper have teamed up to form National Privacy Services Inc. (NPSI) � a partnership designed to help small to mid-sized businesses (SMBs) understand and comply with Canada�s federal privacy legislation.

According to David T.S. Fraser, chair of McInnes Cooper's privacy group in Halifax, NPSI helps SMBs avoid the expense of building a solution from scratch, spending a great deal of time trying to become privacy experts themselves, and/or ignoring the legislation and risking their businesses by being identified as non-compliant. "

Full article ...

Tuesday, April 06, 2004

Article: CMA - Why we changed e-marketing rules

The Canadian Marketing Association, which had been one of the strongest voices in favour of PIPEDA, has amended its Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice to deal with spam:

ITBusiness.ca: "Canada's largest marketing industry group has amended its Code of Ethics and Standards of Practice to deal with the growing volume of unsolicited commercial e-mail.

The Canadian Marketing Association said the amendments would apply immediately to all 800 of its corporate members, and would be specific to e-marketing programs.

Under the new rules, CMA members must obtain a consumer�s explicit or opt-in consent before disclosing their e-mail address to a third party; use the e-mail address only for the purposes that have been disclosed to the consumer; and clearly identify the CMA member and source of the e-mail. They must also provide the recipient with a simple and easy-to-use e-mail means to opt-out from receiving further e-mail marketing communications from the marketer.

CMA communications director Ed Cartwright recently spoke with Pipeline about the changes...."

Monday, April 05, 2004

Article: Security scare for business laptops

Security and privacy go hand in hand. While this article, Security Scare for Business Laptops, primarily deals with confidential business information, the principles also hold true for personal information that an organization is obliged to safeguard under PIPEDA's dictates. Insufficiently secured Wi-Fi can be a significant vulnerability for any computer user and computer network.

The Financial Times: Security Scare for Business Laptops

Business travellers are unwittingly making company secrets available to rivals by ignoring the risks of local wireless networks, known as wi-fi hotspots, security experts warn.

IT security experts who have carried out checks at hotels, railway stations and other public places equipped with wireless internet access technology have found the networks and users' computers are often insecure. "It's actually happening: there is competitive intelligence being gathered," said Richard Hollis, chief executive of Orthus, a security firm.

Hackers - who need little specialist knowledge - can access contents of a rival's laptop because other users' files are visible to anybody using an unsecured wireless network. Hackers are also using wi-fi hotspots to store their files on other computers.

Saturday, April 03, 2004

McInnes Cooper and Thor Solutions Team Up to Provide Affordable Privacy Solutions

NEWS RELEASE

Attention Business Editors:

McInnes Cooper and Thor Solutions Team Up to Provide Affordable Privacy Solution to Small and Med-sized Businesses

April, 2004, Halifax – Thor Solutions Inc. and McInnes Cooper have formed National Privacy Services Inc. (NPSi) to provide businesses with a cost-effective solution to the new privacy legislation.

            “Businesses have a long list of things to do to comply with the new legislation governing the handling of personal information,” says David T.S. Fraser, Chair of McInnes Cooper's Privacy Group. “We help them avoid the expense of building a solution from scratch, spending a great deal of time becoming privacy experts themselves, or ignoring the legislation and risking their businesses by being identified as non-compliant.”

            “Our solution is cost-effective and immediate,” says Dale Telford, Chief Privacy Officer of NPSi.  “It provides businesses with the tools to quickly become compliant through policies, procedures, consent strategies, a multi-media training program and their very own out-sourced privacy officer.  The Common Sense Privacy Solution is very affordable for smaller organizations. “It is focused at small- and medium-sized businesses that are at high risk, such as medical practices and insurance brokers,” says Telford. “We can act as the privacy officer, helping both the business and the customers. We save our clients time and money by dealing with queries, access requests and complaints. We can answer their questions and provide critical support”

            “This law applies to every business that handles personal information in the course of commercial activities. Without an effective privacy plan, businesses are at risk of having their reputation significantly damaged. NPSi is designed to give businesses the tools they need, at a price they can afford, to reduce the risk. The last thing a growing business needs is to be named as non-compliant by the Privacy Commissioner or end up in Federal Court,” says Fraser.  “Addressing the new privacy law is prudent risk-management. Given the risks of non-compliance and the cost of our program, this truly is a common sense solution.”

About National Privacy Services Inc.

National Privacy Services Inc. (NPSi) (www.privlaw.com) was founded in 2003 by Thor Solutions Inc. and McInnes Cooper in order to assist businesses, professionals and industry associations in following privacy best practices, based on the information privacy requirements of the federal privacy law and similar provincial statutes.

Thor Solutions Inc. (www.thorsolutions.com) is a recognized leader in the field of information security. McInnes Cooper (www.mcinnescooper.com) is Atlantic Canada's largest single law partnership with a nationally recognized privacy practice.

NPSi's focus is to provide guidance and support to organizations as they adopt mandatory privacy best practices. We work closely with industry groups to design privacy programs that can be easily and efficiently adopted without interfering with the operations of the organizations required. In addition, we provide full support to our clients, with toll-free, on-call expertise and our privacy professionals can act as the designated privacy officer for our clients.

- 30 -

Media contacts:
David Fraser, McInnes Cooper (902) 424-1347 cell: (902) 478-6654 david.fraser@mcinnescooper.com
Dale Telford, Thor Solutions (902) 469-8467 cell: (902) 830-1981 dale.telford@thorsolutions.com