Interim Privacy Commissioner makes recommendations to Parliament for intelligence oversight

This Special Report to Parliament on surveillance oversight is important and will hopefully be carefully considered by the government of Canada:

News Release: Interim Privacy Commissioner provides recommendations to Parliament for the protection of privacy rights in national security efforts - January 28, 2014

Ottawa, January 28, 2014 — On the occasion of International Data Privacy Day, a special report to Parliament by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, with specific recommendations to address current issues surrounding privacy and national security, was tabled in Parliament. Building from consultation with a range of experts and civil society, the Office’s report makes a series of recommendations for Parliament to consider in order to strengthen privacy protection. Specifically, it suggests ways to increase transparency, modernize privacy laws and bolster Parliament’s oversight role.

“Revelations surfacing over the past months have raised questions among many Canadians about privacy in the context of national security,” said Interim Privacy Commissioner of Canada Chantal Bernier. “While a certain level of secrecy is necessary within intelligence activities, so is accountability within a democracy. Given our mission to protect and promote privacy, and our responsibility to provide advice to Parliament, we are putting forward some recommendations and ideas for Parliamentarians to consider on these important issues.”

Increasing transparency

The report recommends measures to increase transparency when it comes to privacy protection to give Canadians a better understanding of the collection, use or disclosure of personal information in the context of federal intelligence activities.

For example, the Communication Security Establishment Canada (CSEC) could make public more detailed, current, statistical information about its operations regarding privacy protection, and submit an annual report on its work to Parliament, as does the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS).

Reforming federal privacy laws

The report also renews recommendations to amend privacy laws to increase the accountability of federal institutions collecting personal information, as well as businesses that share personal information with authorities.

The Privacy Act, which applies to federal institutions, should require organizations to demonstrate the necessity for collecting personal information and to better promote privacy when such data is exchanged with foreign governments. Changes should also be made to broaden the grounds for Federal Court review to cover institutions’ collection, use and disclosure of personal information.

The report however noted that while the Privacy Act applies to security agencies, CSIS and CSEC are subject to oversight by dedicated, specialised bodies in the form of the Security and Intelligence Review Committee and the Office of the CSE Commissioner. Parliament has entrusted these bodies to monitor the compliance of CSIS and CSEC with their respective enabling legislation and, among other things, privacy protection.

While oversight for privacy protection in the national security context is divided among multiple bodies, the Privacy Act does not allow the OPC to cooperate with the others. As a result, the report recommends the Act should be amended to enable cooperation.

The report also recommends amending the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act, the federal private sector privacy law, to require private sector companies to publicly report on the use of disclosure provisions that permit organizations to share personal information with authorities without individuals’ consent or court oversight.

Focusing on Parliament’s oversight role

The report recommends as well that a Committee could undertake a specific study of Canada’s intelligence activities and oversight involving academic, civil society, legal, technology and intelligence experts.

“By submitting this report to Parliament, our goal is to contribute to a constructive debate about accountability for the protection of individuals’ privacy in this new age of national security threats,” added Interim Commissioner Bernier. “In striving to protect public safety, it must not be forgotten that the right to privacy is fundamental in our democracy.”

See also: Special Report to Parliament – Checks and Controls: Reinforcing Privacy Protection and Oversight for the Canadian Intelligence Community in an Era of Cyber-Surveillance