Sunday, August 21, 2011

Federal Court awards minimal damages under PIPEDA

The Federal Court has recently released its second decision in which damages have been awarded for a breach under PIPEDA. Once again, the degree of damages are very low considering the costs associated with seeking redress before the Federal Court, but this very likely turns on the unique facts of the case.

In Landry v. Royal Bank of Canada, 2011 FC 687 (CanLII), the applicant was embroiled in what appears to be a bitter divorce and was hiding certain bank accounts from her spouse. Her bank was served with a subpoena to produce records. It appears that the bank did not follow its prescribed procedures (which would have avoided the entire mess) and ultimately faxed the applicant's bank records to counsel for her spouse. The applicant complained to the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, who found her complaint to be "well-founded and resolved".

The applicant started an application in the Federal Court, seeking at least $75,000 in damages. Neither party looked good appearing in court: the bank had not followed its procedures and tried to cover it up. The applicant was essentially caught trying to hide assets contrary to her legal obligations in connection with the divorce proceeding.

In the result, the Court concluded:

[32] Taking into account the contributory fault of the applicant, who was partially responsible for her own problems, and the serious breach committed by the respondent’s employee and its subsequent cover-up, the Court finds that the applicant suffered humiliation under paragraph 16(c) of the Act and that the respondent’s negligence warrants the applicant being compensated but does not give rise to exemplary damages as requested. Consequently, we fix an amount of $4,500 with interest and costs to be paid to the applicant by the respondent.

What is interesting is that the Court awarded any damages at all. The records, if they had been properly processed, would have been released to the applicant's husband and the personal result to her would have been the same. The Court could have said "no harm, no foul", but awarded damages (which are at least symbolic). This may hold out some hope for applicants that, in the right case, substantial damages may be awarded.

Tuesday, August 02, 2011

Upcoming panel on WikiLeaks, National Security and Free Speech at the ABA in Toronto

I've been invited to be on an amazing panel discussion at the American Bar Association's annual meeting next week on WikiLeaks, National Security and Free Speech. My co-panelists include lawyers from the ACLU, CNN and the American University in Washington DC. The panel will be on Saturday, August 6 at 3:45 in the Metro Toronto Convention Centre, Room 803 B, 800 Level. If you're at the ABA, come by and say hello. See: Ethics of Social Media, Wikileaks and Courtroom Tech Among Topics to be Explored at Annual Law Meeting – ABANow – ABA Media Relations & Communication Services.

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Live chat on privacy and facial recognition systems

As part of the Globe & Mail's ongoing series on facial recognition systems and privacy, I've been invited to be part of a live, online discussion at 1:00 Eastern on Wednesday.

Here's the blurb they've put up:

What are the risks of facial recognition software? - The Globe and Mail

Facial recognition software is practically ubiquitous these days, whether you realize it or not. This week's Time To Lead series has looked at how it's been rolled out, from banks and casinos to the online world. The Globe editorial board says that the information the comes from this software should not become a commodity.

Are the legal protections in place sufficient? What are the privacy implications of facial recognition software?

Join us for online to delve further into the subject. David Fraser, a privacy lawyer and partner at McInnes Cooper in Halifax, will take your questions, in a live chat hosted by editorial writer Karim Bardeesy, at 1pm on Wednesday.

Globe & Mail series on facial recognition

This week, the Globe & Mail is running a series of articles and opinion pieces on the use of facial recognition technologies. They're worth a read:

Thursday, July 21, 2011

TSA to roll-out less intrusive body scanners

Wired is reporting that the United States Transportation Security Administration is beginning to roll out less-intrusive full-body scanners, which apparently don't automatically display a nude image of the traveler: TSA Announces Privacy Overhaul of Nude Airport Scanners | Threat Level | Wired.com.

Friday, July 15, 2011

Cloud computing and privacy

Today, I will be giving a presentation during a "Town Hall" meeting at the University of New Brunswick as part of their roll-out of cloud computing services for students. I've been asked to address privacy and security aspects of cloud computing.

Here's the presentation, if you're interested:

The video of the presentation is posted on YouTube.

Monday, July 11, 2011

Social sciences research using social media data: Harvard's Privacy Meltdown

This is a really interesting case, and case-study in the complicated privacy and ethical issues of using "person level" social networking information for social sciences research. In this case, researchers "friended" students on Facebook to pull their data into the study. No consent was obtained. The study passed the institutional review board of Harvard, which concluded that getting opt-in consent would not be legally or ethically necessary.

"Alerting students risked 'frightening people unnecessarily,' he says.

'We all agreed that it was not necessary, either legally or ethically,' Mr. Kaufman says."

For the full story, see: Harvard's Privacy Meltdown - Technology - The Chronicle of Higher Education.

Via Lauren Weinstein.

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Dilbert: Employee locator device

Dilbert comic strip for 05/27/2011 from the official Dilbert comic strips archive.

Alberta Court says claims for invasion of privacy must go to Commissioner first

In the recent case of Martin v. General Teamsters, Local Union No. 362, 2011 ABQB 412, the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench struck a portion of a plaintiff's statement of claim related to invasion of privacy, holding that the plaintiff must first complain to the Information and Privacy Commissioner before appearing in court:

Paragraph Nine

[43] It is alleged:

On or about June 2009 and again on or about August 24, 2009 Bernie Haggarty, Business Agent for the Defendant violated my rights with regards to the release of private medical information without first obtaining written consent.

[44] Bernie Haggarty has filed an Affidavit in response to this allegation denying that he improperly released any private medical information of the Plaintiff as alleged or at all, and showing the circumstances of his involvement in efforts to allow the Plaintiff’s employer to evaluate whether or not it accommodate the injury restrictions of Ms. Martin. He deposes that Ms. Martin was present when he sent the information and that he did so wholly with her consent.

[45] This claim appears to be one of invasion of privacy. In Bank of Montreal v. Cochrane, [2010] A.J. No. 1210, Kent, J. discussed claims for breach of privacy, paras. 6, 7 and 8:

6 The second arguable claim is for breach of privacy. BMO first says that if there is a statutory claim for breach of privacy both provincial and federal legislation require certain conditions to be met before a claim can be brought before a court: see Personal Information Protection Act,S.A. 2003, c.P-6.5 and Personal Information Protection and Electronics Documents Act, S.C. 2000, c.5, ss.14-15. These preconditions have not been met.

7 If the pleading claims a common law claim for breach of privacy, BMO argues that there is no such claim: Mohl v. University of British Columbia,[2009] B.C.J. No. 1096 (B.C.C.A.). BMO also argues that the litigation process is intended to be a public process so that anything contained in pleadings cannot be a breach of privacy.

8 I agree with BMO.

[46] In the case referenced by Justice Kent of Mohl v. University of British Columbia, the B.C. Court of Appeal noted at para. 13, “there is no common law claim for breach of privacy”.

[47] If a claimant wishes to make a claim for damages arising from a breach of privacy, the Personal Information Protection Act, S.A. 2003, c.P-6.5requires a claimant to proceed with his or her claim before the Commissioner appointed under that Act. If the Commissioner makes an Order under the Actagainst an organization, an individual affected by the Order then has a cause of action against the organization for damages for loss or injury that the individual has suffered as a result of the breach of the Act by the organization. (Para. 60 of the Act)

[48] Therefore, claims for a breach of privacy which have not first proceeded before the Commissioner cannot be heard by the Court. Further, the Affidavit evidence of Bernie Haggarty on this matter, uncontroverted by the Plaintiff, satisfies me that there is genuine issue to be tried. Paragraph 9 would be struck pursuant to Rule 3.68(a). However, on the uncontroverted evidence of Mr. Haggerty it is dismissed.

Friday, July 08, 2011

Saskatchewan court considers lawful authority

The Provincial Court of Saskatchewan has just ruled that a police officer in the midst of a drug investigation has "lawful authority" to ask for and receive information about a customer of a car rental company, including the customer's contract and photocopy of the renters' drivers license. The Court held that Section 7(3) of PIPEDA was satisfied by the request and that Budget Rent A Car was able to hand over the info in the absence of a production order.

See: R v Siemens, 2011 SKPC 57

[51] Lastly, I am not satisfied that the information contained in the Budget Rent-a-Car contract or attached documents exposed any intimate details about the accused’s lifestyle or information of a biographic nature. The information in the contract included the accused’s name and Mastercard number. It also included a copy of the accused’s driver’s license which provided a photo of the accused, his driver’s license number, his address, his height, weight, eye and hair colour, sex, birthdate, issue date, expiry date, class, endorsements and restrictions.

[52] A lot of this information is personal to the accused but it does not reveal intimate details of his lifestyle or his personal choices. In today’s world we have become increasingly dependent on the Internet and technology. Some of the information such as name and address are readily available on the Internet or in a phone book. I heard no evidence that the accused went to any lengths to keep this information out of a phone book or off the cyber highway. People use credit and debit cards to purchase things or make payments. A driver’s license gives an individual the privilege to drive a vehicle and it has become a very common form of identification. Indeed, it is one of only a handful of acceptable identification when it comes to purchasing alcohol or cigarettes, travelling on an airplane within Canada, when cashing a cheque, when picking up merchandise already paid for, among other things. It is also used by retailers to deter and detect fraud. All provinces in Canada have given police the right to request a driver’s license from someone driving a vehicle to verify the identity of the person driving to ensure that they are legally driving. Barring evidence to the contrary about a particular person, such reliance on driver’s license and technology reduces the expectation of privacy that that person can expect in the information contained in these things.

[53] It is also significant to note that the disclosure of this information did not lead to the police obtaining more intimate details of the accused’s lifestyle or choices such as sexual orientation, religion or personal likes or dislikes. The only thing the information revealed was that Lindsay Siemens had a driver’s license and a credit card and rented the red Cobalt that the police saw meet with Ms. Holmes and Mr. Soare in Rosedale, Alberta. It was only after the police did further investigation that they satisfied themselves that Mr. Siemens was the person who met with Ms. Holmes and Mr. Soare and that he was involved in the drug trade.

[54] Taking into account the nature of the information in question, the fact that PIPEDA was complied with the lawful authority of Constable Hicks to request the information pursuant to section 47.014(1) and Phelps Leasing’s right, in accordance with its contractual arrangement with the accused to disclose the information to a police officer engaged an active investigation, the accused did not have an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy in this information.

In the end, the court found the information was not unlawfully obtained, was not an unreasonable invasion of privacy and therefore did not offend Section 8 of the Charter.